John’s of Bleecker Street

"Will Wallace said it is the best pizza in the city, and this guy knows his pies."

@gino.guerra.canessa98

"Great pizza, very sweet. Like Regina’s a lot"

@rogbert

"One of my top 3 pizzerias in NY "

@mcdalti

"Eric / newyorkcity.fr Le lambris en bois, les niches classiques et les tableaux colorés font de John’s Pizza toute une expérience. Vous y rencontrerez des personnes branchées, des artistes sans-le-sou, de vieux italiens du quartier et beaucoup de célébrités (peut-être seulement en photo). Vous pouvez seulement commander une pizza entière que vous pouvez facilement partager à deux ou trois. Les pizzas sont faites dans un four au feu de bois. Voilà pourquoi elles ont toutes la croûte fine, croustillante et bien cuite. Les ingrédients sont frais, la sauce est piquante et le fromage est de bonne qualité. La pizza au fromage (Cheese Pizza) est la pizza de base. Puis, vous avez un large choix de garnitures. Vous pouvez aussi commander une bouteille de bon vin à prix raisonnable. Les pizzas ne sont pas chères : les prix pour une pizza commencent à partir de 21 $. La pizzeria est super pour le déjeuner et le dîner, mais attendez-vous à une file d’attente."

@assoun31

"Partager une pizza à 2 Authentique pizzeria familiale Manger sur place possible 11h30-22/23h "

@krodlhye

"une des plus anciennes Pizzeria de NY."

@laure21

"vidéo gurky https://youtu.be/BlayAzN7jIs?si=TDXnkGvjH70y2BBv"

@florence.lamirault

"L’une des premières pizzerias de New York, datant de 1929."

@iquartz

"Rob’s Pizza Tour - STOP 2 Rating: 3.5"

@meghanbyrnes

"original John’s pizza from 1921 "

@roxo972

"Grosses pizzas à composer et à partager. Sympa mais la pâte de veux pas celle des Napolitaines"

@lisa_frstr

"really good nyc style pizza, really big too (ehole inly not by the slice) a bit expensive (~25/pizza)"

@arsen.aeby

"Pizza historique de New York "

@bambi_darling

"Une des meilleures pizzas de NYm"

@solene.bedel

"Loved this pizza. Waited w ben on a fri night, only had to wait for 15 min- got the sasso- it’s their plain w some extra seasoning. Absolutely would go again"

@rzanfardino25

"Queue moves very quickly, fun atmosphere but pizza not that great nor wine - defo overhyped would probs try another place tbh."

@annabelkwright

"Sit down pizzeria with beer. Full pies only. Top tier shit."

@festercarbuncle

"pizzas incroyables, surtout la margherita + pas trop cher venir tôt car pas de résa et bcp de monde "

@jennifer.schertzer

"Delicious sit down pizza, line moves quickly! "

@zoeracette

"24$ = 1 pizza large pour 2 personnes"

@sophie63

"Great pizza. Old school spot. Must try at least once. "

@chefnate

"Ouvert tous les jours de 11h30 à 22h (23h vendredi et samedi)"

@celman4

"Coal brick ovens. More pies than slices"

@jbriel

"Barstool Best pizza in nyc"

@keithpatrickconlon13

"My favorite pizza place in NYC. The genuine NY style Pizza "

@olivierth

"Dicono sia la pizza più buona di New York"

@alicepozzati

"pizzeria historique de New York qui a été vue dans plusieurs films pour son cadre authentique et sa pizza renommée. Toutes les personnes qui sony venus ici ont ecrits leurs prénoms sur les tables et les murs "

@sixe67

"Fila e no take away. Pizza intera e no slice. Mancava il sale."

@giulispi

""l'originale" Matthieu PbM"

@mayo_jaune

"Pizzeria historique Greenwich"

@francois.moret.world

"une de mes rues préférées à NY"

@e.klk

"One of one bite pizza reviews favorites "

@joeyv00

"Punky’s favorite pizza place "

@vnairpm

"meilleure pizza chère dans une église rénovée en restaurant"

@babelle

"Got the fifty it was too much, but good spot "

@mncherry

"best pizza new York City NYC best pizza When living in New York City, there’s a lot to be grateful for. For example, you can spend years searching for the best pizza in New York City and find places that will amaze you time after time. There’s no shortage of pizza shops to choose from so it’s hard to know which spots you shouldn’t miss. That’s where this list comes in, I’ll cover my top 15 favorite pizza spots in New York City — and you better believe this girl has HIGH standards for pizza. While you read this list, keep in mind that this is my personal list of the best pizza in New York City. We all have different taste buds, so some folks would rank these joints differently, and that’s just fine! I guarantee that 80% of these pizza spots would show up on both our lists. It’s pizza, enjoy! 😉 This post is dedicated to my friend Jay, who loves pizza even more than I do. But I’m catching up. Best Pizza NYC Types of pizza in New York City Here’s a quick rundown of the types of pizza you’ll find in New York City (textures vary by type of pizza). My advice? Be open, try it all. You never know what you’re going to love. Coal oven & wood oven : Coal oven pies are usually sold whole and come out with a delightful char. These pizzas tend to have flat crusts with a satisfying bite, typically served with light sauce and cheese. Coal-burning ovens are grandfathered in NYC, meaning the only way to get one is to inherit one. As such, wood oven pies are becoming more common. The biggest difference between the two is that coal burns at a higher temperature than wood — so coal-fired ovens provide a crispier crust and more enhanced char. Probably more info than anyone needs, but there you have it. New York Slice: The iconic slice of pizza most folks think of when they visit NYC. These joints sell pizza by the slice (and whole pies too). Slices are thicker than coal oven pizzas and are typically served on a paper plate with napkins in hand. Meant to be enjoyed outside at a standing table or en route to a park — fold, eat, repeat. Sicilian: A square slice of pizza with a doughy crust. To compensate for the crust, these pizzas are usually served with a generous portion of sauce and toppings (think double-cupped pepperonis). Neapolitan: A pizza with family in Naples, Italy. Typically served as personal pies, these have a soft center with a chewy texture. Expect droopy slices bursting with flavor (when done right). best pizza in New York City Best Pizza New York City #15. Di Fara Opened in 1965 to Italian transplant Domenico (Dom) De Marco, Di Fara has been a labor of love for over 50 years. Working 7 days a week for decades, De Marco had an uncompromising and relentless pursuit to create the best pies for his customer. After his passing in March of 2022, New Yorkers from all over flooded the pizzerias social media pages with words of support and love. The significance Di Fara has on the neighborhood and New York City as a whole is palpable. His kids have continued De Marco’s legacy, consistently churning out the best pizza in New York City. The pizzeria is as busy as ever, with their notoriously famous long lines. Nearly every ingredient is imported from Italy, and every pie is topped off with their signature freshly cut basil. A lot of folks attribute the unique and exceptional taste to the generous helping of olive oil that douses each pie both before and after coming out of the oven. They also recently opened a new location in lower Manhattan that is sure to elevate their already significant cult following. Margaret De Marco, who is Dom’s daughter, has mentioned her goal is to expand the brand so long as there is no compromise on quality. Address: 1424 Ave J, Brooklyn NY 11230 & 108 South St, New York NY 10038 Di Fara Best Pizza NYC Image Courtesy PMQ Pizza Magazine #14. Kesté Chef and owner Roberto Caporuscio learned the secrets to making pizza in Naples, and has brought those skills to the US. Having previously opened successful pizzerias in New Jersey and Pennsylvania, he opted to try his hand in New York City opening Kesté in 2009. It’s is the type of place you go to when you want a fancy dinner, but are too much of a New Yorker not have pizza. A fine dining experience, complete with an array of exceptional Italian wines, it can make a great spot for a relaxed date. As U.S. President of PAF Pizza Academy Foundation Caporuscio has begun to teach the craft Neapolitan pizza making to chefs in the US. While he’s away, his daughter who has the same passion and drive as he, runs the pizzeria. Like a lot of the greatest best pizza in New York City, Kesté is a family affair. Kesté is well known for their fried pizza, and before you run off thinking it’s a greasy disaster you oughta give it a try. They use regular dough and fry it for 30 to 45 seconds, top it with the ingredients and throw it in the oven. When it comes out the oil has evaporated, the cheese has melted and presto, fried pizza. Address: 66 Gold St, New York, NY 10038 Keste Best pizza nyc Image Courtesy Kesté #13. Ribalta Bringing the authentic taste of Naples to Greenwich Village, Ribalta is a beloved and treasured New York City pizzeria. It’s not uncommon to hear Italian chatter among the dining guests and if Italians love it you know its good. Pasquale Cozzolino is founder and pizzaiolo at Ribalta. He’s mentioned that in Naples, you have to apprentice for two years before they even let you touch the dough. Making pizza is an art, and Ribalta has gotten it down to a science. It consistently puts out some of the best pizza in New York City. For fans of soccer (especially Italian Serie A) Ribalta is a hotspot. They play games on a projector and tables are full of food and drink with clamoring fans bickering, cheering, and celebrating. And when the national team plays? Welcome to Stadium Ribalta. The namesake pizza is beautifully simple. Italian sausage and broccoli top delectable Neapolitan pizza dough making for a delicious pizza pie. Address: 48 E 12th St, New York, NY 10003 Ribalta Best Pizza NYC Image Courtesy Open Table #12. Una Pizza Napoletana Visiting Una Pizza Napoletana might taking a little planning since it’s only open 3 days a week (and only until they run out of fresh dough!). However any notions of thinking it’s not worth the stop during your precious weekend are misplaced. Una Pizza Napoletana will be the highlight of the weekend, guaranteed. Pizzaiolo Anthony Mangieri was born in New Jersey and growing up begged his mother to take him to every famous pizzeria in the tribe-state area. That budding affinity for pizza has led him to dedicating his life to creating the best pizza in New York City and he’s come pretty damn close as far as I’m concerned. After moving Una Pizza Napoletana six times (including a trip to the west coast), it now calls the Lower East Side home. One of it’s moving boxes is sure to contain the award they won from 50 Top Pizza, the premier Italian pizza experts. The award is for 2022’s best pizza in the United States. No matter which pizza you choose your tastebuds will thank you for the flavorful bites. The Bianca is especially memorable and it’s even beautiful to look at. Address: 175 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002 Una Pizza Napoletana Best Pizza New York City Image Courtesy The New York Times #11. Mama’s Too! Mama’s Too! is a small hole in the wall pizzeria on the Upper West Side that’s generating waves for the best pizza in New York City. Having only opened in 2017, it lacks the storied history of the other best New York City pizzerias. What lacks in history though it makes up for with over the top flavor, this newcomer is creeping up on the crown. With it’s continued rise in popularity New Yorkers are traveling from farther and farther away to try Mama’s Too!. It’s not uncommon to have to wait more than 2+ hours for your pie on the weekends (so order online and skip the line!). Serving both classic New York slices and Sicilian squares its sometimes hard to choose. But choose you must, they don’t allow change orders or customizations. They know what they have is gold and they won’t allow anyone to tell them otherwise. Why would they, so many New Yorkers consider them the best pizza in New York City. As far as my recommendation, you have to try the Angry Nona. If that brings back memories of your grandma chasing you around with a belt I’m sorry. This Sicilian slice combines a hot salami with Calabrian chili oil and hot honey for a *chef’s kiss* pizza. Address: 2750 Broadway, New York, NY 10025 Best Pizza NYC Mama's Too! Image Courtesy The New York Times #10. Patsy’s Pizza Originally opened in 1933, Patsy’s is a grandfathered coal-oven pizzeria living up to the responsibility of churning out exceptional pies. Unlike most of the other places mentioned on this list, Patsy’s is actually an Italian restaurant that just so happens to serve pizza. Considering this, it’s impressive that their pizzas can steal the show in a city peppered with restaurants specializing in pizza alone. We ordered the original pie and were taken aback by the rich complexity of of three simple flavors (dough, sauce and cheese). The crust was thin, as to be expected with a coal-fired oven, and the sauce to cheese ratio was executed perfectly. My favorite part was the flavor of the sauce, it’s so memorable. We weren’t surprised to learn that Frank Sinatra considered this one of his favorite pizzas in New York City, it’s delicious! P.S. We just moved into a new apartment a mere two blocks from Patsy’s Pizza (send help, I have no control). Type of pizza: Coal oven pizza, whole pies only. Pasty's Pizza NYC Patsy’s Pizza | Best Pizza New York City #9. Joe’s Pizza (Iconic NYC pizza by the slice) Joe’s Pizza is on every single “best pizza in New York City” list we came across and during our visit it became clear why. Joe’s is the quintessential New York City pizza slice! It’s not fancy but it’s always fresh, hot and delicious. The crust is nicely charred and the pie boasts the perfect ratio of sauce to toppings. Plus the cheese is never the wrong texture (apparently no easy feat). Simply put, it always hits the spot, which is why there’s a line every hour of the day. To that end, there’s no arguing that Joe’s is one of the most iconic New York City pizzas you can get. Plus, they’re open until 4am, making this a go-to spot for a late night meal after a show or event. Our friends have a fun annual tradition, they greet the first day of spring with a whole pie from Joe’s Pizza in Washington Square Park. Type of pizza: Classic New York City slice Tip: Joe’s Pizza is CASH-ONLY and there’s an ATM right outside the store. Best pizza New York City Joe’s Pizza, a classic NYC slice of pizza! #8. Scarr’s Pizza Within a bite, my husband proclaimed Scarr’s as the absolute best pizza in New York City. Fighting words, I know! But he has a point. I mean, I don’t know if we were exceptionally hungry or something, but Scarr’s Pizza was so good that we returned the next day for more. The Sicilian grandma slice was so satisfying but the pepperoni took the cake. The large slices demand to be folded and the thinly stretch dough is the ideal canvas for the delightful marinara sauce and quality toppings. The cheese and marinara sauce form a harmonious union without overwhelming. In effect, this pizza is everything a pizza should be — simple and delicious! Plus, extra points for the incredible staff here. The man that took our order (both times) was so friendly and enjoyable. In a city where good food sometimes comes at the expense of good service, Scarr’s stands a mile above the rest. Plus, the unfussy storefront definitely evokes old school vibes. Types of pizza: Classic New York City slice and Sicilian. The slices vary on a daily basis (I think pepperoni and cheese are always offered unless sold out. Then you’ll need to wait for the next pie). Address: 22 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002 New York City best pizza #7. Lucali Pizza Lucali is one of the most popular pizzerias in New York City and has the long lines to prove it. The restaurant doesn’t accept reservations, which means the only way to get a pie is by waiting in line (usually for 1+ hours). Serving some of the best thin crust pizzas in New York City, guests are welcome to bring their own beer and wine to cap off the meal properly. But take note, this is a cash-only establishment, so come prepared! Address: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231 Best pizza in New York City Image courtesy: Photo by Vivien Killilea/Getty Images #6. Prince Street Pizza Prior to documenting our search for the best pizza in New York City, we did a TON of research by reading endless articles and reaching out to locals. One place that seemed to appear on everyone’s list was Prince Street Pizza. Since no stone can be left unturned, we promptly made plans to visit. We were surprised to find a line at 2pm (making sure to avoid the lunchtime rush) but thankfully it moved quickly. The store itself is really interesting because walls are adorned with photos of the owner with celebrities. This is a very welcome distraction as the intoxicating smell of pizza enriches the air. All the slices looked so tempting but we settled on the classics — a square slice of pepperoni and a slice of Mercer Margherita. HOLY COW! This pizza is SO delicious! The pepperoni square was the clear winner and I’d gladly take a 30+ minute subway ride to get another slice. The double-pepperoni cups are sheer perfection (why hasn’t this been discovered earlier?!) and the dough is perfectly chewy with a satisfying crust. The line at Prince Street Pizza is completely warranted, this is easily some of the best pizza in New York City. Type of pizza: Classic NYC slice + Sicilian Address: 27 Prince St A, New York, NY 10012 Best Pizza NYC Prince Street Pizza | Most popular pizza in New York City #5. Lombardi’s Pizza Some people make the mistake of assuming Lombardi is for tourists. How wrong they are. This iconic pizza shop boasts an incredible achievement — it’s officially the first pizzeria in America. In fact, Lombardi is credited with developing New York Style pizza. Reason alone to visit, right? The original location is located in Little Italy and is offering outdoor seating during COVID. The pizza is some of the best in New York City. The crust is perfectly charred in a coal oven and the toppings complement the chewy dough while letting all the flavors shine. I suggest ordering the original marinara, pepperoni or the clam pie. During our last visit we ordered the clam pie and can’t stop thinking about it. It’s SO good! Type of pizza: Coal-oven pizza, whole pies only, “personal” size. You can split one pie between two people if you’re not too hungry. If you’re really hungry, I suggest ordering a pie per person. Address: 32 Spring St, New York, NY 10012 Best New York City pizza #4. John’s of Bleecker Street John’s of Bleeker Street is an iconic New York City pizza shop that was founded in 1929. Much like the walls adorned with photos of countless celebrities and windows dressed in awards, the pizza here will keep you coming back time and time again. The crust is perfectly chewy and charred (thanks to the grandfathers coal-fired oven) and the sauce-to-topping ratio is worth writing home about. The pizza is served fresh out of the oven so you can expect hot and delicious pizza within 20-minutes of sitting down (if you’re lucky enough to forgo an hour long line). Type of pizza: Coal-fired, whole pies only. Pies are large and can easily be split between two people. Half/half pizza orders are okay."

@amyogeek

"apparently good according to the internet"

@matthewes

"apparently good according to the internet"

@matthewes

"Bonnes pizzas et lieu sympa"

@silvia911

"Une des meilleure pizza de NYC"

@latok

"should get medium with protein or large with no protein"

@bkivdatemap

"Conseil de Shelly et Katy : meilleure pizzeria de NY"

@toumillle59

"Everywhere says this is the place. This is where you take people from out of town. The sauce is bright. The famous faces are on the wall. The initials are carved in the table. The beer in pitchers. The cheese slightly nutty. The crust a little burnt. A top 5 for sure."

@wtsfyi

"bonnes mais pas les meilleures"

@marine_glts

"Une des meilleures pizzerias de NY paraît-il"

@truffe

"Chris said this place is so good "

@jenna.pasquale304

"Pies only. “Patsy’s style”—halfway between neopolitan and classic NY."

@michaelwsherman

"Jean recommendation- famous pizza "

@laurettevanzanten

"Some of the best pizza in the city "

@julia.perry17

"the pizzas are HUGE and honestly one of the best i ever ate, no joke. Downsides tho: pricey (but worth it) & long ass queue to get a table (especially on weekends). Other than that 10/10"

@urfavremi